GPSR and product liability: two laws side by side
The difference lies in the legal jurisdiction. The GPSR is public law: a regulator such as the NVWA (Authority for Consumers and Markets) enforces it and can remove your product from the market. The Product Liability Directive is private law: an injured party goes to court and claims compensation. One regulates market access, the other the bill afterwards.
The two are often confused because they both concern unsafe products. Yet they are separate. The GPSR sets requirements for you before you sell. The Product Liability Directive only comes into play once damage has occurred. You can comply with the GPSR and still be liable. The reverse is equally possible.
| Feature | GPSR | Product Liability Directive |
|---|---|---|
| Legal jurisdiction | Public law, market surveillance | Private law, civil liability |
| What it regulates | Whether you may sell the product and what you document | Who pays for damages in case of a defective product |
| Who takes action | The regulator, in the Netherlands the NVWA | The injured party, via the court |
| Legal text | Regulation (EU) 2023/988 | Directive (EU) 2024/2853 |
| Applies from | December 13, 2024 | December 9, 2026 |
| Consequence of a problem | Product withdrawn from market, fine | Compensation, without a ceiling |
What the GPSR requires of you
The GPSR imposes public law obligations on you before you sell. You must perform an internal risk analysis, prepare technical documentation, and keep it for ten years. There must be a responsible person established in the EU. Your distance selling offer must state the manufacturer and safety information. The NVWA monitors compliance.
The GPSR is the General Product Safety Regulation. It acts as a safety net for consumer products and applies to risks not covered by specific legislation. The core principle is that a product must be safe and that you must be able to substantiate this. Specifically, it requires, among other things:
- A responsible person in the Union. If the manufacturer is outside the EU, this role falls to the importer, an authorized representative, or a fulfillment service provider.
- Technical documentation and a risk analysis, available to the authorities for ten years.
- Four details for every distance selling offer: the manufacturer, the responsible person for a manufacturer outside the EU, data to identify the product, and safety information.
- A recall obligation with a free solution for the consumer: repair, replacement, or refund.
If you do not comply, the NVWA will enforce. This can lead to an order to withdraw the product from the market and a fine. The GPSR therefore affects your market access, not your wallet after an accident.
What the Product Liability Directive regulates
The Product Liability Directive regulates strict liability. If a defective product causes damage, the producer pays, even without being at fault. The injured party only needs to prove the defect, the damage, and the causal link. Directive (EU) 2024/2853 replaces the 1985 regulation and removes the liability ceiling.
In the Netherlands, this liability is set out in Article 6:185 of the Civil Code (Burgerlijk Wetboek), which is based on the European directive. Your level of care is not a defense. The state of the product determines the outcome. The new directive tightens this in three areas:
- Software is now considered a product. Firmware, apps, and AI systems are covered, regardless of how they are delivered.
- The liability ceiling is removed. The old upper limit on total liability has been scrapped.
- The burden of proof shifts. In the case of a technically complex product or a thin file, the court may presume the defect, shifting the burden of proof to you.
Countering this are the defenses in Article 11 of the directive. The defect did not exist when you placed the product on the market. You followed mandatory regulations. The damage was caused by a change beyond your control. Every defense stands or falls with the evidence in your file.
One defective product, two laws
Take an imported fan that causes a fire due to a melting plug. The GPSR determines that the NVWA can withdraw the product from the market and demand a recall. The Product Liability Directive determines that the victim can recover their damages from you. The same defect, two separate procedures.
The two tracks run parallel and meet in your file. The NVWA requests your technical documentation to assess whether you placed the product safely on the market. The court or the insurer requests the same documentation to assess whether you can substantiate a defense. Anyone who only has one of the two in order will still get stuck on the other track.
Who is liable for production in Asia
If you have products manufactured in Asia and put your own brand on them, you are the manufacturer under both laws. Under the GPSR, you bear the responsibility of the producer; under the Product Liability Directive, you can be held liable as the producer. The importer who brings the product into the Union runs the same risk.
This is the point that hits private labels and imports hardest. You are not just buying stock; you are buying the manufacturer’s responsibility. The price of the product says nothing about the magnitude of that risk. And under the new Product Liability Directive, the authorized representative is also a party that can be held liable, ensuring the chain around the foreign manufacturer is fully covered within the EU.
Are you unsure whether both laws apply to your product?
Briefly let us know which product is involved. We will contact you regarding what we can do and the associated costs.
Why your GPSR file is your best defense
The file that the GPSR already requires of you is your means of evidence under the new Product Liability Directive. If you cannot produce the documentation, the court may presume the defect, and the burden of proof shifts to you. The risk analysis and test reports are precisely what substantiate the defenses in Article 11.
This is where the two laws converge. The technical documentation, risk analysis, and traceability you establish for market surveillance are the exact evidence with which you counter a damage claim. A brand that manufactures in Asia can only limit its liability under the new directive with the file that the GPSR already makes mandatory. A thin file is thus your greatest exposure; a strong file is your best defense.
If you substantially modify a product, you become the liable party for it once again. Therefore, create a separate file for each model variant and record when the modified version was first placed on the market. This ensures the evidence stays with the product you are actually selling.
Which dates to keep an eye on
Two dates drive your file. The GPSR has applied since December 13, 2024, so those obligations are already in effect. The Product Liability Directive applies to products placed on the market from December 9, 2026. Record for each article number when a product was first placed on the market, as that determines which regime applies.
The old product liability regulation from 1985 will be repealed on December 9, 2026, but will continue to apply to products placed on the market before that date. Two regimes will therefore exist side by side, separated by the date of first placement on the market. Recording that date is a small administrative step with a major impact in the event of a dispute.
What to arrange now
First, map out which products you sell under your own brand or as an importer, as you run risks under both laws there. Check whether your technical documentation matches what is currently in the box. Record the date of first placement on the market for each article number.
- Determine for each product whether you are the manufacturer or importer, as this determines your position under both laws.
- Check whether the technical documentation and risk analysis are up to date and belong to the current product.
- Register the date of first placement on the market per article number.
- Identify which products contain software or firmware and who supplies them.
- Schedule a fixed time each year to compare the file against the product being sold.
- Regulation (EU) 2023/988 on general product safety (GPSR), Articles 9, 16, and 19, text on EUR-Lex
- Directive (EU) 2024/2853 on liability for defective products, Articles 8, 10, and 11, with the repeal of Directive 85/374/EEC as of December 9, 2026, text on EUR-Lex
- Civil Code (Burgerlijk Wetboek) Book 6, Article 185 on liability for defective products, wetten.overheid.nl
Legal expert with a background in e-commerce. Writes about the rules he applies daily in files for brands and manufacturers. More about Francois
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the GPSR or the Product Liability Directive apply to my product?
Does the new Product Liability Directive replace the GPSR?
Does my GPSR file help with a damage claim?
When does the new Product Liability Directive take effect?
Would you rather be certain that your file holds up?
We audit your technical documentation and risk analysis and prepare the file that withstands both market surveillance and damage claims. A fixed-price proposal within 24 hours.
View the CE process